Saturday, January 29, 2011

Looking for examples of BAD genetics journalism

The students in my introductory genetics class have an unusual assignment - each of them has to find an error in the reporting of genetics and write a letter to the editor about it.  They're not very skilled at finding examples of such errors (and I'm afraid I haven't given them much time), so I'm asking the twitterverse for help.  If you've recently wrung your hands about some egregious error in the reporting of some advance in DNA or genetics research, we'd be very grateful if you would post a link (or other identifying info) in the comments.

Here's some more information about the assignment:

The students are asked to find somewhere in the media where an incorrect statement is made about a genetic topic. This could be in a tabloid, newspaper or magazine, on television, or in a news-media online source.  (General blog posts are not eligible, though media-affiliated ones are.)

These students are only part-way through their first genetics course, so the error needs to be pretty basic.  Examples I've given them include
  • describing genome sequencing as 'cracking the genetic code'
  • describing a bacterium with arsenic in its DNA as 'a new form of life'
  • credulously reporting about the predicted effect of what turns out to be an imaginary gene
  • claiming that gene A causes behaviour B, when it only slightly increases the probability of the behaviour.
The students write a draft letter to the editor (polite, concise, in correct English), and then do a complex peer review of each others' drafts, using Calibrated Peer Review (CPR).  (UBC's Centre for Teaching, Learning and Technology is setting this up for us on a trial basis, as nobody here has used it before.)  They then polish their letter, submit it for final grading, and (we hope) also send it to its destination.

The present class is only 40 students, but if this assignment works well (and the CPR works well) we'd like to run it for 500 students next Fall.  This would lead to a barrage of letters to the editor complaining about the poor quality of their genetics coverage, and might even lead to an improvement in future reporting.

22 comments:

deevybee said...

I assume I should not say what I think is problematic but leave it to your students to work out?
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-11437079
DM me if you need more info.

deevybee said...

Here's another one:
http://www.express.co.uk/posts/view/204642/Curvy-women-Body-shape-is-down-to-genes

Raychelle said...

This doesn't sound quite like what you're looking for, but the "Prosecutor's Fallacy" is an egregious example of DNA stats reporting. Reporters fall victim to it as well: http://bbc.in/hY4z6P

Baju Kebaya Pengantin Muslim 2015 said...

I found your blog when I was looking for a different sort of information but I was very happy and glad to read through your blog. The information available here is great.I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this post.

Anti Rayap said...

Please visit:
Toko Bunga Jakarta
GPS Tracker
Cotton Bud
parfum

happy wheels games said...

Thanks for the best blog.it was very useful for me.keep sharing such ideas in the future as well. Thanks for giving me the useful information. I think I need it!
friv4 | friv 4 school | kizi4 | kizi 4|unblockedgames unblocked games for kids

happy wheels said...

Thank you very much for your post, it makes us have more and more discs in our life, So kind for you, I also hope you will make more and more excellent post and let’s more and more talk, thank you very much, dear.
happy wheels| friv|monster high| shooting games| tetris| 8 ball pool
cool math games| barbie games| friv4school| agario| sudoku

hoa huy said...

Big Farm

Big Farm is an awesome multiplayer farm management game made by the Goodgame Studios.
Your mission is simple: Create a big farm, grow crops, breed animals,
and become the richest farmer of the universe. Enjoy Goodgame's Big Farm!

Tangki Fiberglass said...

A very insightful information and it very helpful. In case need some info about atap fiberglass. Thanks for sharing.

Kelly Anni said...

Thanks for sharing this quality information with us. I really enjoyed reading.
slither io | wings io | science kombat | tank trouble 4

Lisa M. Henry said...

Hotmail is an email account of Microsoft Corporation. Like Google's Gmail, it is full of features usually xuyen.Neu of an email you want to register an account please follow these basic steps:
Hotmail login

Hotmail review

Sign in to hotmail

Login to hotmail

Recover hotmail password

Tank Trouble is a very interesting flash game about tanks, about war and about destruction
TANK TROUBLE | TANK TROUBLE 2

One Penguin Takes it personally when he is surfing the web and stumbles upon a web site telling him that he cant fly, after that he sets his mind to research and practice flying until he can prove the world that he can..
Slitherio | LEARN TO FLY | LEARN TO FLY 2

Strike Force Heroes is a new game action-packed shooter from the creators of Raze; with 3 game modes, 15 campaign missions and over 65 weapons.
Strike Force Heroes | Strike Force Heroes 4

Strike Force Heroes 2

Giải Trí Tổng Hợp said...

I was working and suddenly I visits your site frequently and recommended it to me to read also. Age Of War 2
Big Farm | Slitherio
Tank Trouble | Happy Wheels
Goodgeme Empire | Slither.io

Trần Mi said...

Busy life circumstances than the current world history. Must try to earn money to support themselves, their families and pay for living. But not so that you neglect your own health, but more must cherish it.
geometry dash , geometry dash game , geometry dash 2.0 , geometry dash

Trần Mi said...

I used to play games after long day of work tired or bored. And I would recommend to everyone a very interesting game and attractive for both color and sound
run 2 , run 2 game , run 2 unblocked , run 2

Trần Mi said...

How often do you play games on free time or after hours of work stress? I usually come to the game as a way to balance life is full of pressure. And I would recommend to everyone that I loved the game
strike force heroes 2, strike force heroes 2 game, strike force heroes 2, strike force heroes 2 game, strike force heroes 2

Linh Hoa said...

In your article, points caught my attention the most is how your prose, to give me a deep impression. Wish you would write more. good luck!
baixar facebook , baixar facebook gratis , facebook baixar ,

Linh Hoa said...

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.
baixar whatsapp , baixar whatsapp gratis, whatsapp baixar,

Linh Hoa said...

I think what you say on here is the best thing. Looking forward for our lives become increasingly more beautiful
return man 2 game , return man 2 , return man ,

Linh Hoa said...

Just remember your stab at this business, should you decide to end it, is not a failure but a training ground. You will take with you what has worked and learned from what has not in order to make the next business idea a success!
subway surfers game ,subway surfer , subway surfers

Surfers Subway said...

Great! Thanks for sharing the information. I like this information. Keep posting
Subway Surfers
Subway Surf
Subway Surfers download

HayleePh said...

Thanks for the job post. For more of such kind of jobs, you can refer to the link below.
friv100 | Friv 10 | zoxy 3 | agar.io

Kizi 2 said...

I liked it so much and very interesting, too! Thanks for sharing the experience.
Wonderful post, really great tips and advice.
friv 3
friv 4
kizi 2
friv.org
zoxy games